Note: If I unintentionally spoil for a plot point, my apologies. I'll try not to, but the warning is there for the spoilerphobes (which I am, on occasion, especially about the series that run in the weekly Shonen Jump in Japan, ha :3).
First off, my favorite part about Ann Rinaldi's historical books is the note on the back cover that is a "warning" telling readers they might actually -
gasp! - enjoy the book they are about to read. Oh, Ms Rinaldi, every time I see that blurb I mentally tell myself "I always enjoy her books! Duh!" because it is just so dang true. Anyone who loves historical fiction should read Ann Rinaldi's rather lengthy bibliography, which I am only a portion of the way through, although by the time I do, she'll probably have several new books out on the market!
All right, on to the book:
An Acquaintance with Darkness, which takes place right after the Civil War in Washington D.C.; Emily Pigbush, a girl of only fourteen years is forced to take care of her sickly mother all by herself. She is friends with Annie Surratt, whose brother Johnny is the target of a very secret crush by Emily.
When Emily's mother dies, she is forced to take shelter with her uncle, Dr. Valentine, who for some reason Emily's mother dislikes terribly (understatement of the year, actually, as she forbids Emily to live with him after her death.) Why? Well, after her mother's death, President Lincoln sees a play -- and we all know how
that turns out. The hunt is on for John Wilkes Booth, and Annie's mother is arrested as she was close friends with Booth; Johnny is also forced to stay in hiding as he too is suspected of having a hand in the assasination.
The story evolves into this: Emily lives with her uncle and his assistant, the clever Marietta who is a medical assistant and botanist; they develop a very unsteady relationship, their personalities clashing as equally-stubborn people are wont to do on occasion. There is also Maude the housekeeper, and Robert, a soldier wounded in the Civil War who becomes Dr. Valentine's student in medicine. It becomes a tale of morality as Emily discovers that her uncle traffics dead bodies to continue his studies, and practically everyone in the house is aware of it.
Now you know the story, here are my loves and dislikes about the book.
I Loved: Emily Pigbush. She's a realistic, headstrong female leading character, a fresh breath of air in an era of weeping dainty ladies and such other stereotypes. What amazes me is that she does not trust anyone straight off in the Valentine household, and Rinaldi makes it clear that a country's bitter racial past is evident in Emily's view towards Marietta, who is part black. The story is carried by Emily's moral struggle towards Marietta, Dr. Valentine's work in the shed, the world of the girls in the school, Robert, the Surratt family's struggle in the hands of the law. I emphasized for Emily deeply; she's a confused girl without any parents, forced to accept a strange new world without being told the truth, so she goes and finds it. That's important: Emily doesn't wait around for an explanation; she
goes and finds it, and feels betrayed when she does.
Also, in the scene where she declares she does not wish to be Little Miss Muppet anymore; it takes a long and painful journey to get to that point, but the delivery and the afterwards is so freaking worth it. Favorite character of the book? Yes, ma'am.
I Loved: The over-arcing theme of secrets. Secrets in Dr. Valentine's work, in the loyalties of most of the cast, in what is really the truth. Washington D.C. post-Civil War is a confusing place, and Rinaldi guides us through it with skill and artistry both superb.
I Loved: Dr. Valentine. Can I call him a BAMF? Okay, I will: he's a freaking BAMF, in the quiet and collected kind of BAMF, not the Neville Longbottom cut-snakes-in-half type, natch. He's smart and clever, doesn't care about race when he enlists Marietta as his medical assistant, and is the voice of reason throughout the whole novel. Yet, you can tell he also struggles morally with the fact that he has to keep the truth of his work away from Emily's eyes, only because he believes (rightfully so, imho) that she is not yet ready to understand the complexities behind it all.
I Superly-Duperly Loved: Marietta. Can we has spin-off novel now? Florist by day, medical student turned body snatcher in the name of science by night? That would just about rock outloud, if Rinaldi could manage to find a plot suitable enough for Marietta (who is also a BAMF, imho).
I Disliked: The body snatching. I know, it's not the main focus of the book -- Emily is, her and her story, but hold on. The book does not address the racism that was prevalent in the body snatching industry, the disrespect brought to corpses of color. IMHO, that wasn't just Atlanta's medical schools. Am I asking for too much? Probably, but I wanted to put this in.
I Disliked: Needed MOAR MOLE AND SPOON, heh. I kinda liked them in a curious way, I wish they'd been there more.
Last Note:
An Acquaintance with Darkness is, in one word, awesome. It has drama and action, science and romance, moral struggles and orphan cats, and BAMF characters all around. Seriously. You like historical fiction in YA? Do you know people who do? Read this freakin' book already.